Browse By

Dear 21 Jump Street,

The circumstances behind your creation have rightly given some people pause. No one wants another half-baked remake of a “classic” that trades on nothing but snark and cynicism to get winking chuckles from those who are willing to poke fun. A great comedy asks us to invest in characters and events, and draws humor from the ways in which the things we see subvert or pervert our expectations.

Luckily, the people both behind and in front of your camera understand this, and saw your core story elements not as an excuse to play lazy and detached, but to create a commentary about the way in which our culture has changed, and to find new levels of humor to exploit within that idea, and with the boon of an R rating.

The particulars of your story remain largely unchanged and patently familiar. Two comically mismatched rookie cops are recruited into a special task force that takes youthful officers and places them undercover in high school to bust up drug rings, car thieves, and any other teenage miscreants that they happen across. One cop is skilled in the physical mechanics of the job, the other is intelligent but lacks in almost every other regard. They forge an unlikely friendship, butt heads with commanding officers, et cetera, et cetera.

Jonah Hill and Channing Tatum in 21 Jump Street.

The difference in your story, however, is the shared history that these officers have. They both attended high school together, they both know one another as they were before they donned the uniform. This familiarity, and the parallel it draws with their new assignment, and the way their expectations are turned upside down, form the main dramatic and comedic skeleton of your narrative. Due to this, their ‘bromance’ comes across as real, grounded, and yet unlikely enough to still gain some traction during their comedic exchanges.

Jonah Hill and Channing Tatum are pretty much perfectly cast in their roles, embodying the broadly drawn personas that have been assigned to them, and yet imbuing their characters with enough heart and skill to make them more than just plot-convenient protagonists.

Over-examination is the killer of comedy, so to explain too much related to plot or the way in which the gags work risks aborting the jokes before an audience has a chance to enjoy them. Let me just say, however, that the manner in which you play with genre expectations, and the way that your characters reflect those subversions is obvious, but in keeping with the characters and situations, and thus manages to do a kind of double-summersault over the pitfalls one would expect this kind of meta-commentary to create. The well-deployed vulgarity, physical comedy, and over-the-top side characters only further heighten this artfulness.

So what else is there to say to you? I went in with high expectations given the surprising amount of love my compatriots had heaped on you, and I was not disappointed. You’re a good movie, a funny movie, and one with a hook for a sequel that leaves me excited rather than exasperated. In this day of undying franchises and easy humor, that’s just about the best thing that could be said about you.

You’re a credit to the force,

Brian J. Roan

6 thoughts on “Dear 21 Jump Street,”

  1. Ric says:

    Well I’ll be double damned …

  2. Fogsmoviereviews says:

    “Over-examination is the killer of comedy”

    Now there’s a truism for ya!

    Yeah, I think we’re on the same page here Brian. Nothing spectacular, just a very funny movie. A solid comedy offering that happened to take everyone by surprise because no one had any expectations.

    Tatum and Hill made a nice comedy duo…

  3. Andrew Crump says:

    I think knowing as little as possible about Jump Street going into it is key to its success. By that I mean, “people should go into Jump Street not knowing that it’s frigging amazing,” but that’s sort of an unrealistic expectation at this point. And besides, we want to talk about movies exactly like Jump Street, because we want people to go out and see them because they’re so frigging good.

    It’s been weeks since I saw this, and man, I really, really want to see it again. Just thinking about it now is giving me the gigs. If I think about it further, I might start tripping major ballsack. Maybe I’m being extra good to it because it’s a movie that’s based on 21 Goddamn Jump Street, but if Bacall, Lord, and Miller were able to get something this good out of something that hokey, then maybe they deserve the extra praise.

    1. Brian J. Roan says:

      I agree, I think my surprise at its quality definitely added to my enjoyment. It’s a movie where everyone involved seems to be having fun, and that definitely comes through. That said, I think it’ll be funnier a second time.

  4. Josh says:

    I can’t believe how much praise this movie has been getting. When I first saw mention of this movie, I certainly expected some stupid, cliched, formulaic movie that proved shallow and only mildly amusing, with maybe a couple fun action sequences. Had zero interest in watching it.

    Hearing all the praise for the movie, though, has me curious to see it. I won’t go to the theater to check it out or anything, but it’s something I’ll definitely at least rent when it hits DVD.

    1. Brian J. Roan says:

      Yea, I was surprised by its quality even after hearing all the praise. I can’t say it needs to be seen in theaters, so DVD is definitely a practical choice. Plus, I bet this film would play well with a group of friends. You should definitely check it out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *